CBO's HR 3200 Analysis
By truth on Aug 28, 2009 | In National | 3 feedbacks »
I have been reading the Congressional Budget Office's preliminary analysis of H.R. 3200. It is interesting reading in light of what other pundits are saying. One such person is Rush Limbaugh, and on his show he made an interesting comment regarding the CBO's analysis of the bill. You can read the transcript of August 14th where he says "this monstrous, 1,017 page bill, after it passes -- ten years after it passes -- there's still 17 million uninsured Americans! It does (I am sure he meant to say NOT but it is missing from the transcript) even accomplish its primary, advertised objective." Well shall we see what the CBO analysis actually says?
In the Congressional Budget's analysis on page three it says "...those provisions would yield a significant INCREASE (emphasis mine) in the number of Americans with health insurance." Here is the part Rush left out, "by 2019, CBO and the staff of JCT estimate, the number of nonelderly people without health insurance would be REDUCED (emphasis mine) by about 37 million..." Now here is where Rush Limbaugh picks it up again, "...leaving about 17 million nonelderly (sic) residents uninsured..." Now Rush decided not to continue from here but I will, "(nearly half of whom would be unauthorized immigrants."
Now first of all Rush called them Americans, ummm Rush are you sure you meant to call unauthorized immigrants Americans? I think I need to go back onto Limbaugh's site and see what he has to say about that subject. I wonder what Limbaugh's position is on illegal immigrants getting health insurance...
3 comments
I am not saying this isn't great ideal, I am saying the loop holes left in this system are going to run us into the ground through abuse. How about before we support our countries existing cheap labour (Mexico, Philippines, India), and we support the previous cheap labour our country was built on, our elders. :o)
Rob, non-citizen legal residents who work here pay taxes just like everyone else. Much of the cheap labor our country was built on in the past was in fact that of immigrants--the Chinese and Irish built our railroads, the Irish, Italians, and many others built our cities in the Northeast. Also keep in mind that emergency rooms are required to treat people regardless of citizenship status, so you are already paying for many low-income immigrants' care, you're just paying for treating them once they've gotten sick rather than preventing them from getting sick in the first place.
Undocumented aliens are explicitly banned from receiving a health insurance subsidy in HR 3200.
This post has 154 feedbacks awaiting moderation...
Leave a comment
| « NC DOT Working on a Sunday? | Creative Freelancer Conference » |

